Start with the condition in which the part will arrive

A finished-part drawing may support two different quotations. Consider a hypothetical steel bracket with one machined face and four holes. The drawing specifies a spacing tolerance for two of the holes. One supplier prices a cast blank with machining allowance. The other prices machining the face and all four holes, with a first-piece measurement record for the specified hole spacing.

Two hypothetical quotations for the same bracket
What to checkCast blankMachined part
MachiningAgree on the blank dimensions and allowance for later machining.Confirm the finished face and four holes are included.
InspectionAgree on which blank dimensions to check before delivery.First-piece hole spacing is included. Confirm any production sampling and reports.
ToolingCheck whether casting tooling is quoted separately.Check how casting tooling and machining fixtures are each charged.

Compare the cost at the same point of delivery

If your machine shop finishes the blank, add its setup, machining and inspection costs before comparing prices. Ask the shop to check that the proposed blank leaves enough stock to clean up the machined face and that it can locate the part for the hole pattern. For quotations that both include machining, compare the same lot size, drawing revision and inspection deliverables.

A Wontide quotation can cover the cast blank, machining, casting tooling, machining fixtures and inspection gauges. Ask which costs are itemised and which are included in the unit price. For transport, request prices on the same trade term and at the same named port. Specify the port of shipment when comparing FOB prices, or the destination port when comparing CIF prices.

Wontide uses iron pattern tooling to form shell moulds from resin-coated sand. We can itemise that tooling separately or include it in the unit price. Compare quotations at the same order quantity and expected total volume, and ask how the tooling is handled on repeat orders.

One published Wontide example is an agricultural equipment bracket made from ZG270-500 cast steel, normalized and delivered machined. For that delivery condition, agree the heat treatment, machining scope and inspection records when requesting prices.

See the machined agricultural bracket case

Make the quotation easy to compare

Send the current drawing, the material specification, any required heat treatment, and separate sample and production quantities. Mark the parts or features that need inspection records, and ask each supplier to list exclusions. If you want prices for both delivery conditions, request two lines for the same drawing revision and state who will handle the remaining operations.

See the steel casting RFQ checklist